Using 73 and 65 boveda packs in same humidor

MorganGeo

I've been using both a 73 and 65 boveda packs in one of my humidors for the past two weeks. I've been getting readings bouncing between 68 and 70 consistently. So my theory is this. Will I ever have to worry about humidification again? It's still a little early to tell for sure but wouldn't the packs consistently humidify each other? Taking and giving between each other. I'm guessing as long as the packs stay plump I'll be good to go for a long time. Anyone tried this?

Rain

Wonder if that would wear them out quicker.

Big''nBall''n

Interesting looking forward to your long term findings.

rsherman24

Or you could just put a 68 in

MorganGeo

rsherman24:

Or you could just put a 68 in

i know. But my thoughts are to see if neither ever dry out.

rsherman24

MorganGeo:

rsherman24:

Or you could just put a 68 in

i know. But my thoughts are to see if neither ever dry out.

Just messin with ya. Had me thinking for a while. Will be interesting to see

90+ Irishman

rsherman24:

MorganGeo:

rsherman24:

Or you could just put a 68 in

i know. But my thoughts are to see if neither ever dry out.

Just messin with ya. Had me thinking for a while. Will be interesting to see

In a perfect lab environment maybe but in the real world with so many outside variables including absorption rates of the cedar, the wood, slight bleed off from opening and closing etc I don't see that happening. It may make it so that you don't have to replace them as often but like I said I just don't think it would self replenish over and over. Hope it works out for you regardless though and that I'm wrong!

Echambers

Morgan! Dude!!!! Don't do it. This is the cigar equivalent of dividing by zero!

Bob Luken

MorganGeo:

I've been using both a 73 and 65 boveda packs in one of my humidors for the past two weeks. I've been getting readings bouncing between 68 and 70 consistently. So my theory is this. Will I ever have to worry about humidification again? It's still a little early to tell for sure but wouldn't the packs consistently humidify each other? Taking and giving between each other. I'm guessing as long as the packs stay plump I'll be good to go for a long time. Anyone tried this?

Dayummmm! You just made me do some thinkin'.......... Please stop.

(I actually have used this method to achieve an RH compromise in small humis. But, I never thought about it much beyond the RH I was getting.)

Martel

IF boveda are truly only single use/good for their factory charge, this could shorten their life as they "give and take," fighting against each other.

OTOH, I've recharged my bovedas and they work, so, who knows? I've done this with a couple and they didn't last much longer than normal.

Sasquatch

You are a rebel!!! That's akin to spittin' in the wind or tugging on Superman's cape

90+ Irishman

Sasquatch:

You are a rebel!!! That's akin to spittin' in the wind or tugging on Superman's cape

Or trying to tell your wife she is wrong. Doesn't work LMAO

Ken Light

::facepalm::

Ok, I get where you're coming from. But remember the point of humidification is to humidify something, i.e. the cigars and the wood in the box (not our goal, but still necessary to maintain rh). So the moisture has to go somewhere besides back and forth and will run out. And as people have said, we don't know what limits these things, and if it's actively humidifying, this might make them go kaput sooner because they will be more active for sure.

In the end, think about it this way. If they lasted forever, no moisture would ever have entered a cigar and then you didn't need them in there at all.

MorganGeo

Ken Light:

::facepalm::

Ok, I get where you're coming from. But remember the point of humidification is to humidify something, i.e. the cigars and the wood in the box (not our goal, but still necessary to maintain rh). So the moisture has to go somewhere besides back and forth and will run out. And as people have said, we don't know what limits these things, and if it's actively humidifying, this might make them go kaput sooner because they will be more active for sure.

In the end, think about it this way. If they lasted forever, no moisture would ever have entered a cigar and then you didn't need them in there at all.

this makes the most sense to me. I knew my goofy theory was too good to be true. Hahaha.

Chemnitz

The boveda packs in my cedar humidors dry out at least twice as fast as the boveda packs in my coolidor. I believe this is because the coolidor is plastic and seals really nice. Not as much moisture escapes. Whereas the wood humidors must be constantly losing humidity and and as a result suck the boveda packs dry. So I think both of your boveda packs will be constantly drying, regardless of whether they are 73 or 65.
BTW, this is one of the reasons I'm very glad I set up the coolidor.

jgibv

73 + 65 = 138
138 / 2 = 69
why not just get 69% boveda packs?

Bob Luken

Chemnitz:

The boveda packs in my cedar humidors dry out at least twice as fast as the boveda packs in my coolidor. I believe this is because the coolidor is plastic and seals really nice. Not as much moisture escapes. Whereas the wood humidors must be constantly losing humidity and and as a result suck the boveda packs dry. So I think both of your boveda packs will be constantly drying, regardless of whether they are 73 or 65.
BTW, this is one of the reasons I'm very glad I set up the coolidor.

This also makes much big good thinking. If you try this in a cooler or tupperware you'd get more transfer between the two but in a wood humi They'd both disperse moisture to a much greater degree and be used up quicker.