Would You Rather...

Chemnitz

Darktower007

Diffrent. I get board to quick to smoke the same thing everyday.

rsherman24

Different. I still enjoy trying new stuff even if I don't love it. If you said a group of 10 cigars for the rest of my life, could probably get by on that.

jd50ae

There are so many different cigars out there and a lot of them are good. I think one could sustain one's love of cigars smoking a different one every day.

twistedstem

Prob different every tie,would never get bored.

matkn293

I would say different as well. Even if you found one you like, there are different sizes and releases that can be obtained and all things considered are different cigars.

No_one21

Definitely different, there's just so many different cigars I'm sure you could have a unique one each time but keep similar to the one(s) you love.

0patience

brianetz1

If you said same 5 cigars for the rest i think i could handle that, but different for me. No way i could do the same one every time.

Rain

Depends. If it was not 100F at 8pm most nights, I would smoke dang near every night. As it stands, I can only brave the heat two times-ish a week. At that rate, I could smoke the same thing every time and not mind. At my optimal smoking rate...different.

danielzreyes

"same cigar thrice a day all day erryday!" - this grumpy old botl

The3Stogies

Wow, that is heavy man, really have to think about that. Right now I would say the same cigar only. I would rather choose my own and live with it if it's good. You know what to expect and should get it from that cigar. I do like trying different ones too, but only 1 would kinda suck, especially if it was really good. If you never had it you won't miss it, yeah maybe stick with 1 cigar. Hope I never have to decide which cigar, I can't lol.

Lee.mcglynn

Being a cig smoker as well I'll take the same one! Too many duds to go through and some are truly horrible

First Warrior

I get bored pretty easy so different is the way I would go. When you get as old as I am it is good to continue to explore the world, cigars included.

Beaker38

brianetz1:

If you said same 5 cigars for the rest i think i could handle that, but different for me. No way i could do the same one every time.

Ibwould agree. A choice between five yes but I would have to say differnt as it is right now

Rain

Beaker38:

brianetz1:

If you said same 5 cigars for the rest i think i could handle that, but different for me. No way i could do the same one every time.

Ibwould agree. A choice between five yes but I would have to say differnt as it is right now

AJ Fresh Rolled, MOW PA, MOW Virtue...I'm good.

Drummerjoe

Different.. I'm just getting started so I have a long long way to go!!

amantedelsigaro

Different ones.Though I have a few favorites. Variety is the spice of cigars... or is it life.

ol_smokey1

Definitely different. In my opinion, trying new cigars is half the fun. Plus, as mentioned previously (at least I think, I just skimmed the thread), you never know what gems you might find that you otherwise would not have tried. Never settle!

Bob Luken

The one I'm smokin' right now is THE one. Pleasantly surprised with this stick from a sprint sale fiver purchase about a year ago. Macanudo Maduro. But tomorrow might be different. We are lucky gentlemen. Very fortunate IMHO. We can choose either option.

The3Stogies

Let's say you decided on a cigar for life. Over the years wouldn't that cigar change, subtly over time, from different crops and aging? Then wouldn't you have a slightly different cigar over time with the same characteristics that you love? Would that make the whole same cigar theory a myth?

webmost

Darktower007:

Diffrent. I get board to quick to smoke the same thing everyday.

too wurds: Spel chekker

webmost

webmost

kuzi16

Martel

Chuck N

Tough decision, but I guess Id go with a different one every time because if I got a turd I could just snuff it and get another.

raisindot

That's a tough one. I generally have to sample 10 different cigars to find one that I really like. I would be very sad if I could never ever, smoke another Fuente Hemingway, My Father or Padron again. Especially if the only untried cigars left were machine-made--or Gurkhas.

Bob Luken

I bet most of you are not paying close attention to the question. If you choose "different" you can never have the same cigar twice. Never again,.......ever. That means the random cigars you come across that happen to be great, you can never have again. Are there that many random cigars that are good enough to outweigh the boredom of smoking the best cigar you've ever had over and over? Very interesting question. I'm leaning toward "same". But picking THE one would be tough. Uh,.................Padron 64 Maddy no wait!.................