Ideal Palate Development Sampler?
Puff_Dougie
Everyone, Registered Users Posts: 3,182
in Cigar 101
This may be a stupid question, but if you were to put together the perfect sampler to help someone new to cigars to develop their palate, what sticks would you include? Would there be an ideal mix of smokes that you think would provide a broad experience of different strengths, flavors, and blends? If you had to pick, say, six cigars for an Intro to Palate Development Sampler, what would they be, and why?
Comments
San Cristobal Elegencia-it's different for Pepin but the flavors are more distinguishable than some Connies thanks to his style.
La Riqueza-nice firecracker by Pete Johnson and Jaime Garcia
AF Hemingway Short Story Maduro-I think this is a good intro to maduro.
Ashton VSG-good intro to how strong can also be smooth
MOW PA-these have so much oil, you can feel it on your lips. So very different from other cigars out there, but still with some interesting flavors.
The last one is a toss up for me. I'm not trying to pick my favorite sticks here; rather, I'm trying to pick ones with some good and distinguishable flavors and different feel, body, and finish. I'm tempted to go with a really mild Connie, either Oliva CT Reserve or Avo Classic. On the other hand, I might suggest the Oliva Melanio for the beauty of the wrapper and a full sensory experience, but I'm a Melanio pimp so I try to rein in my tendency to suggest it. I'd consider JdN Celebracion in the Consul or Corona size. But as I think about it, I might just lean towards the Sol Cubano Cuban Cabinet. I've only had one of these, so that goes out on a limb, but I thought it was good, great for the price. Only problem is that it's another AJ blend. For that reason I might lean toward Avo, some other Kelner blend or even find some other blender to highlight.
I think these are fairly common sticks; nothing super-premium to make a new smoker feel like they had to like the cigar because of the price. Nothing extremely budget, either. Oh, and I tried to pick sticks available from c.com, too.
This thread is a great one. I wish I'd gone this direction when I started, with more of a focus on learning blenders and their style instead of looking for a country or type of wrapper.
My first order was a house blends sampler, but I wish I'd just bought regular cigars. The house blends are fine as they go, but I don't think they represent the best of cigars. They're more a close approximation. Some of the best house blends around, but I don't think they're great for developing a palate. At least I didn't think so. They'd be great as a comparison, though.
I have also wished for a similar sampler. A sampler of cigars that each has one single specific flavor that is obviously dominant over all the others in order to learn how to better detect that single flavor among the other flavors present in a cigar. But I would suspect that an "educational" sampler like this would never exist unless created for that purpose because a great blender wouldn't let a single flavor dominate to that degree. Would they?
Another great suggestion, Dustin! Are there specific sticks you would recommend in each category?
1) "Bombs" A chocolate bomb, a pepper bomb, a leather bomb, etc. etc. so that the person really gets what those flavors taste like.
2) Similar cigars that vary on some major facet, like wrapper, as someone suggested with the La Aurora Preferidos. Another way to do something similar would be one cigar in multiple vitolas to be able to realize the differences that can create.
I feel like for the absolute beginner number one works best. Kuzi has a thread on developing your palette where he suggests actually tasting the flavors before or along with the cigar to really be able to pull them out of the cigar's flavor. That might work well in conjunction, although there is some debate (in the thread) as to whether anyone wants to actually taste leather! Number two might be a good second step if someone is really trying to refine their palette though, so as others have said it depends on experience.
Avo , Perdomo Champagne, La Aurora, Cabaiguan, Mac 2006, Jameson Red, Monte white, Angelenos... Basically an assortment of mild-med conny's from different regions. You will start to notice the differences in tobacco from the different region. Similar wrapper type, yet totally different flavor profiles.
DR try stuff from Henke, La Aurora, Rodrigo, Fuente, etc... Nica DPG, AJ, Plasencia Boutiques, Carlos Fernandez, etc... San Andreas (jsut a suggestion as there is a ton) stuff like Padron, UC, or the many others out there. You could Penn Broadleaf, Ecuadorian Habano, Rosado, etc...
The point i am trying to get at, it back off the heavier cigars and start over light again after a good break. You will notice flavors there you might not have noticed before. As you work your way back up into full bodied cigars, you will look at them much differently. When I take a note, it is normally after I detect a flavor, then drink ice water, and wait to see if that specific flavor is still there in my mind and on my palate after 5-10 minutes. If it is, that's a note. I've been lucky enough to review and get samples from all over, so by making myself look at each cigar by region, blender, body, etc..., I kind of forced myself to grow. At times, it does seem like everything has the same notes. However, when you consider they might all be coming from the same place, that's what sets the good guys apart. The ability to use the same types of tobacco with the same types of notes, yet create a bouquet of complexity that is unique.
In the meantime, I will make it a short term goal to try your suggested strategy of taking a week off from smoking, then working up through the milder smokes. Thanks again for taking the time to educate us!
Cast a wide net & smoke everything. Especially starting off and then start to notice a pattern of flavors like & dislikes then take a closer look at where those cigars came from, wrappers, blenders etc. and you can narrow it down. Once you know what you like you can focus on a narrower path if you choose.
And keep the price low starting out IMO. Nothing like spending $20 on your first cigar and hating it....
MOW sampler FTW??
Maybe, only after smoking MOWFTW though. ,
I would go with the Avo XO to understand musk
Illusione Cruzado for a feel of leather
Emilio AF1 for a good spice
Illusione -R- Rothchildes for a vegetable style sweetness
four kicks for a cedar note
JdN dark corojo for coffee
room 101 connecticut for a licorice note.
onyx reserve for a chocolate note.
Oliva G maduro for a nice earth (on the sweeter side)
thats nine of the most common flavors you can find in cigars. most of the above cigars are generally not hard to find.
for Dominican:
Opus X, Rodrigo La Fortaleza, Davidoff Millennium blend (i know Ecuadorian wrapper)
for Nicaraguan:
Oliva Serie V.
for Honduran:
Punch Gran Puro, Camacho Criollo, CLE Corojo, Humo Jaguar
Cameroon:
Arturo Fuente Don Carlos #4
Cuba:
Partagas Series D no4, Monte 2, Bolavar Belicosos Finos
i wouldnt say that all of the cigars i mentioned in this thread are my favorites but they will give a decent selection of whats out there and what to look for.