If you could only have one cigar, what would it be?

Goldy

If you could have one cigar, regardless of price, what would it be?

Matt Marvel

Only one? Hmm.. I have no idea. Padron '64.

mustluvcigars

tough to just choose one: Padilla 1932

betasynn

Camacho 8/11 or 5 Vegas Cask Strength II. Can't decide.

MAJORdorMo

Carlos Torano Signature

gmill880

Goldy:

If you could have one cigar, regardless of price, what would it be?

Depends on what you mean. If I only get one more cigar for the rest of my life it would obviously be the damn longest one I could find !!! Now if I can only smoke one brand it would probably be a DE Java Toro or a La Aurora 1495/1994 ( I love those) although I'm pretty excited about the Forum Blend Maduro !!!

TatuajeVI

My favorite cigar I have ever had is probably the Camacho Pre Embargo. I've had three of the original five I bought and about passed out due to ecstasy during each of the three. Had a similar reaction to a CAO Vision Prana that had been aging two years.

Luko

If I only get one more before I die, then I have to know I'm gonna like it. I don't want to take chances on a HMR or something like that. In the year or so I'm been enjoying cigars, the three most enjoyable experiences I've had involved a DP Cuban Classic, a RP vintage 1992 and an RP Decade (and subsequent have only reaffirmed my feelings) so I guess at this point I would pick one of those.

bigbgballz

R&J Reserva Real No2 Belicoso

Lasabar

I don't really have a hands down drag out favorite, but if I had to say the cigar that I've enjoyed the most so far would be Romeo y Julieta Habana Reserve or Nica Libre (Haven't smoked my fair share yet, but these things are G-O-O-D)

ejenne87

Matt Marvel:

Only one? Hmm.. I have no idea. Padron '64.

I def. agree with that. It's my favorite so far, always the exact same as the first time I had one.

Grahamcracker

Easy, Casa Magna!

Hays

If I could have only one cigar for the rest of my life, it'd be the Rocky Patel Vintage 1990... Those just call my name every time I walk into the humidor. If I could pick just one to try out of all the possible choices, it'd have to be an aged HMR - if I'm not paying for it, why the heck not?

j0z3r

Ok, my Desert Island cigar would be the La Flor Dominicana Cameroon Cabinet #1. It would be a very close though between that and the Padron '64 toro in the habano wrapper.

vankleekkw

1 last cigar ever - Opus BBMF Maduro

1 type forever - DPG Blue Lancero, Padilla 32 Robusto, or Bolivar Gold Medal. Really tough call

Renaissance_Man

RP Decade Torpedo....

cabinetmaker

I'm not sure what it would be...Padilla 1932, maybe GOF Don Carlos...

laker1963

P!ss off, who could survive on only one cigar for the rest of their life??? LMAO
Actually, there are a few out there that I would have to try before I could answer that. But as of right now... I go back to my first answer:)

These Filthy Hands

My last cigar for the rest of my life...

Fuente Opus X Perfection no. 4

One type for the rest of my life. It would either be RP Sungrown, Oliva Master Blend 3, Camacho SLR Maddy, LFD Maduro Chisel, Illusione MJ 12. I don't know. Every stick I smoke, I seem to like.

JZ

Padron 64

kaspera79

The best cigar I have ever had was a Partagas Serie D #4 That would be my forever cigar.

j0z3r

That's a killer cigar Kas.

Lasabar

kaspera79:

The best cigar I have ever had was a Partagas Serie D #4 That would be my forever cigar.

OH BABY!

I've never had them before, but everyone I know raves about them! And I just happened to have some resting in the Humi!!!!

kaspera79

Lasabar:

kaspera79:

The best cigar I have ever had was a Partagas Serie D #4 That would be my forever cigar.

OH BABY!

I've never had them before, but everyone I know raves about them! And I just happened to have some resting in the Humi!!!!

I think lassie may have just become my new best friend !!

YankeeMan

Monticristo Classic.

24footjet

Padron 1964

laker1963

kaspera79:

Lasabar:

kaspera79:

The best cigar I have ever had was a Partagas Serie D #4 That would be my forever cigar.

OH BABY!

I've never had them before, but everyone I know raves about them! And I just happened to have some resting in the Humi!!!!

I think lassie may have just become my new best friend !!

PM sent Kas.

kaspera79

Hey Laker.. Reply sent.

laker1963

kaspera79:

Hey Laker.. Reply sent.

Got it Kas. Consider it done. I'll be in touch.

rad1964

I have to agree here:

These Filthy Hands:

My last cigar for the rest of my life...

Fuente Opus X Perfection no. 4

And my smoke for eternity would have to be.. [drum roll]

Ghurka Centurian If it's good enough for the Sultan of Brunai, it's good enough for me!

Goldy

Cool, I wanted some ideas of great cigars I need to try and it looks like I have a great selection. I think my cigar would be either a R&J Viejo or a PE comacho.