Rocky Patel vs Indian Tabac

Krieg · January 2009

Which brand do you prefer and why? Which ones have you smoked? Any similarities between the two?

madurofan · January 2009

RP. Indian Tabac's are pretty good buts its definetly second tier.

PuroFreak · January 2009

I've never had any of the ITC but I do have a couple of their 10ths in my humi. I've had many of the RPs and I can't imagine the ITC could be better. The RP Decade and 92 are amazing smokes!

Krieg · January 2009

I just got a couple of ITCs in a sampler, might smoke one this weekend, ill let ya know what i think.

j0z3r · January 2009

I prefer RP to ITC...though I will say the ITC 10th is a darn tasty smoke. Overall though, I prefer the Rocky Patel line, it fits my tastes better.

madurofan · January 2009

Let me say that when I said the IT's were second tier, I wasn't including the ITC 10th.

j0z3r · January 2009

madurofan:
Let me say that when I said the IT's were second tier, I wasn't including the ITC 10th.

Of course not...if I thought that, I'd be on the next flight to (insert where you live) to slap you.

phobicsquirrel · January 2009

I will have to be the odd man out on this, I have had several IT's, and I like them much more than RP. I do like RP's 1990, the 92's are okay but I prefer the 90's. I have an edge, haven't lit it up yet. I've had the rest of the line and wasn't all that into them. I really liked the IT split decision double and triple, wondering if I should order the quad.

madurofan · January 2009

I'll venture out on a limb here and say that if RP had stuck with IT blends he would've been just another now defunct cigar company that made good cigars. The RP 90 and 92 made the company and built his reputation.

PuroFreak · January 2009

urbino · January 2009

I've never had one, either, Puro. I think I've got one -- maybe two -- around here somewhere. I'll have to see if I can dig them up . . . if I ever get rid of this motherlovin' cold.

PuroFreak · January 2009

urbino · January 2009

Thanks, dewd.

madurofan · January 2009

I think I sent you a ITC Cameroon urbi.

urbino · January 2009

You are correct, sir. I found it while I was moving everything over to the new humi. Actually, I found 2 of them. (This is the problem with a big coolerdor.) Did you send me 2?

madurofan · January 2009

After consulting the spreadsheet, no I did not.

dutyje · January 2009

madurofan:
After consulting the spreadsheet, no I did not.

nerd

madurofan · January 2009

dutyje:
madurofan:
After consulting the spreadsheet, no I did not.
nerd

If I've ever seen a case of the pot calling the kettle black ...

Rocky Patel vs Indian Tabac

Comments