Cedar-lined Red Oak Humidor?

Options
The Hoos
The Hoos Everyone, Registered Users Posts: 42
I am making a humidor out of red oak and lining it with cedar. Does anybody have any experience with this type of humidor? Should I complete it and see if it works or start redesigning it as a knick-knack holder for the wife?... lol.

Comments

  • JCizzle
    JCizzle Everyone, Registered Users Posts: 1,910
    I think WaxingMoon makes humidors for a living...
  • xmacro
    xmacro Everyone, Registered Users Posts: 3,402
    It's gotta be spanish cedar, not just any kind of cedar. +1 to asking WM or Cabinetmaker
  • The Hoos
    The Hoos Everyone, Registered Users Posts: 42
    Cool thanks, I'll ask them .
  • dowjr1
    dowjr1 Everyone, Registered Users Posts: 600
    Waxing Moon is the way to go...Ed will help you out OR even better make you one.
  • bigharpoon
    bigharpoon Everyone, Registered Users Posts: 2,909
    If you line it with Spanish cedar than you'll be fine as far as keeping your cigars in a cedar box is concerned. Most humidors are some type of hardwood with cedar lining. Red oak moves quite a bit but if you make it well and have tight, glued edges and a nice fit with the top and the lining is snug there is no reason why it shouldn't be perfect. With the red oak you'll just have to make sure the construction is top notch, that's all.
  • The Hoos
    The Hoos Everyone, Registered Users Posts: 42
    bigharpoon:
    If you line it with Spanish cedar than you'll be fine as far as keeping your cigars in a cedar box is concerned. Most humidors are some type of hardwood with cedar lining. Red oak moves quite a bit but if you make it well and have tight, glued edges and a nice fit with the top and the lining is snug there is no reason why it shouldn't be perfect. With the red oak you'll just have to make sure the construction is top notch, that's all.
    Rockin, thanks
  • bacon.jay
    bacon.jay Everyone, Registered Users Posts: 718
    Red oak is very open-grained too. If you decide that's the way you want to go, I'd use filler in the pores before finishing, which might help prevent warpage, and possibly look better in the long-run.

  • The Hoos
    The Hoos Everyone, Registered Users Posts: 42