Short smokes

Jumper

What's better?
Oliva Special G?
Or Hemingway Short Story?

TheDrifter

Having just had a Hemingway Signature and not being a fan of any of the Oliva blends (blasphemer!!) I'd go Hemingway for sure. Even the signature was a 90 minute smoke though.

Joeyjoe21_8

the G is awesome! one of my favorites...in fact, just got one the other day to smoke tonight

chrisd56

LOVE the short story!

zeebra

Just had the Best Seller over the weekend, and I loved it!

Jumper

Just went out and got one of each over my lunch break. Time to do a side-by-side comparison.

t_evan50

I love them both. Almost equally....gotta go with the Hemi tho.

Russ55

The Hemingway is a no brainer. It's expensive though. The G I need to revisit sometime. So far I've not liked anything Oliva except the V.

AQUADGIO1200

Short story all the way....Special G is you are short on cash.

Jumper

Wow. Kind of surprised no one has taken the G. Seems like there are usually some pretty hardcore Oliva advocates around here.

cods

I like the G,s

kuzi16

I LOVE the G... especially the maduro. however, i feel the Hemmingway is just a better cigar. its hard to compete with the short story. that vitola is one of the best things Fuente has ever done.

lcpleel

I tried both this past weekend and enjoyed both but I have to favor the short story

Fourtotheflush

Ive only had the special G, and wasnt impressed at all.

Jumper

I smoked the G last night and wasn't all that impressed. I didn't think the flavor was very complex at all. Might do the Hemingway tonight or I might let it sit for a few more days. I'm working on some humi issues right now.